Unfortunately, most of the Yuletide fics people have really been raving about are for source materials I don't know. But I went through those I did know and read quite a few fics, most of which were nice but forgettable. There were two that stood out.
The shadows cast behind you by
karanguni PG (The Left Hand of Darkness)
Short but dense and multi-layered. The author is clearly intimate not only with the character and the world, but with Le Guin's style -- rich and very particular about sensory things, yet also cuttingly direct. It really made me want to re-read the book.
The Aunt and the Ankh by
shadow_truths PG (Jeeves & Wooster series)
Funny! A very confident author here, who can certainly do Wodehouse's style, but it isn't just an imitation; they go at it with a rougher, more worldly sensibility that makes the sexual aspects (which are thankfully not overdone) seem fitting and natural. There are always J&W fics in Yuletide that are written with skill, but
so many of them try too hard to splice Wodehouse together with fandom and fall flat on their faces. The author of this one avoided the pitfalls. I wish they would, as the saying goes, rite moar.
eta: Gotta love
pepysdiary today.
"To church in the morning, and there saw a wedding in the church, which I have not seen many a day; and the young people so merry one with another, and strange to see what delight we married people have to see these poor fools decoyed into our condition, every man and woman gazing and smiling at them."eta2: authors