I thought GoF was generally entertaining, but in all of the books there tends to be huge gaps in logic. This books' largest plot hole was the portkey and hence the entire tourament - THAT was the plan? Crouch had a million other opportunities, even with Voldemort recovering for most of the book. And a tournament that has most of it's tasks hidden from its audience?
"OotP proved me wrong there. I still miss the happy sparkly days of the more childish, early books, though. *sigh*"
I haven't reread ANY of the books since the first time because of Teh Angst!11 PoA, for example, with the whole line about 'I can hear the Dementors killing my mum'... But GoF and OotP really stepped it up! I wasn't as content as you with OotP, for many reasons, however.
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
no subject
Date: 2004-04-29 06:58 am (UTC)This books' largest plot hole was the portkey and hence the entire tourament - THAT was the plan?
Crouch had a million other opportunities, even with Voldemort recovering for most of the book.
And a tournament that has most of it's tasks hidden from its audience?
"OotP proved me wrong there. I still miss the happy sparkly days of the more childish, early books, though. *sigh*"
I haven't reread ANY of the books since the first time because of Teh Angst!11
PoA, for example, with the whole line about 'I can hear the Dementors killing my mum'...
But GoF and OotP really stepped it up!
I wasn't as content as you with OotP, for many reasons, however.